Why 4 to 6 Months Is the Best Time to Sleep Train Your Baby

The Ideal Window for Sleep Training

If you're considering sleep training, the 4 to 6-month age range is widely recognized as the best time to start. At this stage, babies are developmentally ready to learn independent sleep skills, making the process smoother and more effective compared to waiting until they are older.

Note, you should never sleep train a baby younger than 4 months of age.

Why Is 4 to 6 Months the Optimal Time?

1. Babies Are Developmentally Ready for Sleep Training
   By 4 months, most babies have the neurological maturity to develop independent sleep skills. Their circadian rhythms are becoming more established, and they are capable of learning how to connect sleep cycles on their own. However, this applies to developmentally normal babies—babies with medical conditions or developmental delays may need a different approach.
2. Babies Haven’t Developed Object Permanence Yet
   Object permanence—the understanding that things still exist even when out of sight—typically develops between 6 to 9 months. Before this, babies don’t yet associate being alone in their crib with separation from their parents. This makes it much easier for them to self-soothe and fall asleep independently without experiencing separation anxiety.
3. Easier to Wean Off Sleep Associations
   By 4 months, many babies have developed strong sleep associations, like needing a pacifier, rocking, or nursing to fall asleep. Since they don’t yet have a deep attachment to these habits, it’s easier to remove them now than at 9+ months when habits are more ingrained. This means that it is a perfect time to wean a pacifier if your baby has a strong suck to sleep association.
4. Higher Sleep Training Success Rates
   Research and anecdotal evidence suggest that babies who start sleep training between 4 to 6 months have higher success rates compared to those who begin later. Studies indicate:
• Cry It Out (Extinction Method): 80-90% success rate within a few nights.
• Ferber Method (Graduated Extinction): 70-85% success rate within a week.
• Chair Method: 50-60% success rate (takes longer but can be effective with consistency).
• Pick-Up/Put-Down Method: 30-50% success rate (more parent involvement required, leading to mixed results).
5. Longer Sleep Stretches for Babies and Parents
   Sleep training at this age allows babies to learn to self-soothe and connect sleep cycles, leading to longer, more restful nights for both baby and parents. Well-rested babies are often happier, more engaged, and less fussy during the day.

Why This Is a Great Time to Ditch the Pacifier

Since babies don’t have object permanence yet, this is also the ideal time to wean off the pacifier if it’s becoming a sleep crutch. If a baby relies on sucking to fall asleep, they may wake multiple times a night searching for it. Removing it during sleep training helps babies learn to settle themselves independently, reducing unnecessary night wakings.

Can You Sleep Train an Older Baby? Yes, But It’s Harder

If your baby is older than 6 months, sleep training is still possible—but it often takes longer and requires more consistency. Here’s why:

• Stronger Habits: Older babies have had more time to reinforce sleep associations like rocking, nursing/sucking, or needing a parent in the room.
• Object Permanence: By this age, babies associate your presence with their ability to fall asleep, which can make sleep training more challenging.
• Separation Anxiety: Around 8 to 10 months, many babies experience a peak in separation anxiety, making sleep training more emotionally challenging.
• More Resistance: The longer a baby has relied on sleep props, the more resistant they may be to change. This doesn’t mean sleep training won’t work—it just requires patience and consistency.
• Increased Mobility and Stronger Sense of Self: Older babies and toddlers often have a stronger sense of self, more mobility, and developing language skills, which can make changes to their routines more challenging.

The Bottom Line

The 4 to 6-month window is the easiest and most effective time to start sleep training. Babies are developmentally ready, object permanence hasn’t set in yet, and success rates are high. If your baby is older, sleep training is still possible—it just requires a bit more persistence. It’s always a good idea to consult your pediatrician for guidance on when to start sleep training, as they can help ensure it’s the right time for your baby’s unique needs.

Looking for a step-by-step sleep training guide? Simple Parenting Plans offers expert-backed sleep training programs designed to help your baby sleep better, starting tonight!

Legal Disclaimer: The information in this blog is for educational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice. Always consult your pediatrician for specific guidance regarding your child’s sleep and health. For more information, visit the CDC’s Safe Sleep Guidelines.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. I only link to products that I truly believe in. This means I may earn a small commission when you click on links to Amazon products in this post, at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting Simple Parenting Plans!